Finfish.org

Significant Aquaculture Innovation

Home Trading Post Problems To Be Solved About Contact Us Finfish Feed

Comparison of aquaculture cages

November 16th, 2008 by ibthi

There are a number of blogs on the finfish site regarding different aquaculture cage technologies. However, there was little information in the way of a comparison between the different technologies. I came across a presentation which provides some insight. The presentation provides an interesting comparison of some aquaculture cage products commonly used in North America. The aquaculture cages compared are:

 

  • SeaStation by OceanSpar, USA
  • Aquapod by Ocean Farm Technologies, USA
  • OceanGlobe by Byks ASNorway
  • Ocean Drifter by MIT Sea GrantUSA

The presentation also considers some information on the economic viability of open ocean aquaculture of a number of important fish species. Finally, the economics of nearshore versus offshore aquaculture is considered.


Like to read more? Subscribe with RSS RSS2

6 Responses to “Comparison of aquaculture cages”

  1. Maadhu Jinu

    According to Aquafeed, Goudey conducted the tests at Snapperfarm, Inc., an offshore fish farm that has been growing cobia in submerged cages for five years. The spherical cage, developed by Ocean Farm Technologies, Inc. of Searsmont, Maine, was an Aquapod with a capacity of 3,250 m3.
    More information on the subject can be found at:http://www.thefishsite.com/fishnews/7715/selfpropelled-aquaculture-cage

  2. Ocean Farm Technologies

    That was certainly an interesting presentation and it is always encouraging to see attention and curiosity surrounding open ocean fish farms and the pens used for them. It is worth emphasizing that only Ocean Farm Technologies’ Aquapod and Ocean Spar’s Sea Station have been built and deployed in North America. Furthermore, Ocean Farm Technologies has installed additional Aquapods beyond the ones mentioned in the presentation and continues to do so on a global scale.

    The technology and feasibility to raise fish in high energy offshore conditions continues to advance on a daily basis. We are optimistic that this type of aquaculture production will play an ever larger role in the industry as producers and the public embrace this more sustainable approach to fish farming.

  3. ibthi

    Thanks for the clarification. Do you think you could provide more information on latest developments and in the feasibility you mentioned. I posted information on the presentation above because it specifically mentions cost comparisons (per cubic metre).

    Do you think you could provide some up to date information on the costs of the aquapod cages and how that compares with a near shore cage of similar size. I think we all understand that the deep ocean cages are more expensive, but it would be interesting to quantify the difference.

  4. Ocean Farm Technologies

    That is a lot to cover but I’ll try and touch on everything briefly.

    The long term success of offshore operations will require successful automation of many standard operating procedures to reduce overall operating costs, minimize labor, improve safety and further reduce environmental impacts. Of course all of this will improve the overall feasibility of offshore production. Ocean Farm Technologies (OFT) is actively working on and testing means to realize some of these long term goals. One example of this would be automation of pen rotation. This will allow cage cleaning/surface drying to be conducted on a schedule with minimal user input required, thereby freeing many man hours and ensuring fouling is kept to a minimum.

    Without getting into considerable specifics, it can be said that at this point in time that the initial costs of offshore submersible pens are higher in general than near shore floating pens. Yet, the important thing to understand is that the lifetime costs of a submersible offshore pen when compared to floating net pens is very comparable. The labor and cost to clean, repair and remove netting from floating cages in conjunction with the risk for escapes and damage from storms greatly escalate the long term costs of near shore pens. It is also valuable to consider the reduced disease opportunity and optimized growing conditions that crops will benefit from in open ocean environments when looking at costs.

    Pricing is variable depending on many different specific factors but OFT is happy to discuss these with interested parties and help develop reasonable cost estimates.

  5. Naime Emir

    Dear Sir

    Delta Aquaculture Equipment Ltd.We product aquaculture equipment like HDPE cage, cage nets etc, and we product HDPE boats

    We are able to provide low price good quality HDPE boats.We have CE certification from Istituto GiordanoS.p.A in İtaly.Our product characteristics changes demand of customer.

    We are to construct every kind of cages according to region’s features from the most hardest sea conditions to the most protective areas with our experienced staff.

    the best quality nets which are appropriate for your cages and boats. At our established workshop in Milas/Mugla we are cutting, sewing and rigging of them.

    We are to establish the disign of every type fish production facilities on sea, land and fresh water areas.

    At this moment, Delta made cages were reached the number of 2000 ,in Turkey
    Delta produces and rigs 300 ton nets per year.

    We are seeking a partnership or importer from all over the world countries
    We have ISO 9001:2000 certification
    Payment will be accepted cash in advance with the order confirmation.

    http://www.deltaqua.com/

    If you are interested do not hasitate to contact us.
    Best Regards,
    Naime Emiralioglu

    naimeemiralioglu@hotmail.com
    Tel : 0216 309 96 57

  6. Robot That Jumps Like A Grasshopper And Rolls Like A Ball Created For Space Exploration | Working in Oil and Gas

    [...] Soccer/Football/Foosball Robot! | zedomax.com …Blogs That May Also be of interest Spherical CageComparison of aquaculture cages1000th visit and some Compressed Sensing “humour” « Le Petit …East Bay Events and Arts [...]

Leave a Reply


Subscribe to the comments for this post with RSS: RSS2 RSS 2.0